Elementary
- 2004/05: Jean Rupp, Kindergarten, Frankstown
- 2005/06: Diane Kline, 1st grade, Frankstown
- 2006/07: Diane Vella, 6th grade, Foot of Ten
- 2007/08: Ann Hess, 5th grade, Foot of Ten
- 2008/09: Catherine Rodgers, 2nd grade, C.W.L.
- 2009/10: Rachel Black, Kindergarten, Frankstown
- 2010/11: Phyllis McConnell, Art, Frankstown
- 2011/12: Connie Tomassetti, Kindergarten, C.W.L
- 2012/13: Matthew Stinson, 6th grade, Frankstown
- 2013/14: Kimberly Nicewonger, Kindergarten, Foot of Ten
- 2014/15: Lisa Surkovich, Reading Specialist, C.W.L.
- 2015/16: Brandy Gregg, Kindergarten, Frankstown
- 2016/17: William Madden, 5th grade, C.W.L.
- 2017/18: Martha Miller, Music, Foot of Ten
- 2018/19: Jaime Hartline, 6th Grade, Frankstown
- 2019/20: Derek Trimmer, Librarian, Frankstown
- 2020/21: Dr. Sarah Palazzi, Reading, C.W.L
- 2021/22: Alyssa Carpenter, 2nd Grade, Foot of Ten
- 2022/23: Kim Bridenbaugh, Kindergarten, Frankstown
- 2023/24: Kelli Singer, 4th Grade, C.W.L
Secondary
- 2004/05: Glenn Stevens, Science, JH
- 2005/06: Rick Imler, Biology, SH
- 2006/07: Sue Gunsallus, English,SH
- 2007/08: Renetta Deremer, Math, SH
- 2008/09: Wendy Jo Nagy, Music, JH/SH
- 2009/10: Karen Natoli, Math, JH
- 2010/11: Linda Bufalini, Biology,SH
- 2011/12: H. Jean Sinal, Environmental Science, JH
- 2012/13: Scott Sheehan, Music, SH
- 2013/14: Alysia Watt, Art, SH
- 2014/15: Kevin McCloskey, Biology, SH
- 2015/16: Barb Wertz-Leidan, Art,JH
- 2016/17: Leah Haslam, English, SH
- 2017/18: Andrea Walter, Biology, SH
- 2018/19: Veronique Stern, Foreign Language, JH/SH
- 2019/20: Robert Valeria, Math, Junior High
- 2020/21: Melissa Jack, Math, Senior High
- 2021/22: Andrew Tinker, Biology, Junior High
- 2022/23: Lindy Hilling, Business Teacher, Senior High
- 2023/24: Lynette Luke, AP Chem Teacher, Senior High
